Randomized controlled trial · 2018
Open-Label Placebo Treatment for Cancer-Related Fatigue: A Randomized-Controlled Clinical Trial
Hoenemeyer TW, Kaptchuk TJ, Mehta TS, Fontaine KR
Scientific Reports, 2018 · PMID 29426869
In short
Cancer survivors with persistent fatigue took openly labelled placebo pills for three weeks alongside their usual care.
- Study type
- Randomized controlled trial
- Published
- Scientific Reports, 2018
- Topics
- Open-label placebo, Cancer survivorship, Fatigue
open-label placebo cancer-related fatigue?
In this 2018 trial, cancer survivors who took openly labelled placebo pills reported greater improvement in fatigue severity and fatigue-related quality of life than those receiving usual care — a notable result for a symptom with few effective treatment options.
Cancer-related fatigue is common after treatment ends and has few effective options, which makes it a frequently studied outcome in placebo research.
The question
Can openly labelled placebo pills affect self-reported fatigue and fatigue-related quality of life in cancer survivors?
How it was done
- 74 cancer survivors reporting at least moderate fatigue, randomized to three weeks of open-label placebo or to treatment as usual.
- After the three-week period, the control group was offered the placebo regimen for three weeks, and the placebo group could continue.
- Outcomes were fatigue severity and fatigue-disrupted quality of life on validated self-report scales.
What was reported
- The open-label placebo group reported greater improvement in fatigue severity and fatigue-related quality of life than treatment as usual.
- Controls who took placebo in the second phase also reported improvement.
- Some improvement in the placebo group persisted through the follow-up period reported by the authors.
Limitations
- Modest sample size and entirely self-reported outcomes.
- No blinded placebo arm.
- Fatigue fluctuates naturally after cancer treatment, and a no-pill control does not fully account for attention and monitoring effects.
Why it matters
It extended open-label placebo research into a survivorship population and into a symptom with limited treatment options, and it is one of the most frequently cited trials in the field.
Citation
Hoenemeyer TW, Kaptchuk TJ, Mehta TS, Fontaine KR. Open-label placebo treatment for cancer-related fatigue: a randomized-controlled clinical trial. Sci Rep. 2018;8:2784.
PMID 29426869This summary is written by Efficacy Labs and is not a substitute for the original publication. The research described here is independent work by third parties and was not conducted using Efficacy Labs products. Efficacy Labs products contain no active therapeutic ingredient and are not intended as substitutes for prescribed medication or professional medical care. Information on this website is provided for general educational and research purposes and is not medical advice. References to published research describe independent scientific literature and do not imply that the research was conducted using Efficacy Labs products unless explicitly stated.
Background
What the placebo effect is, explained simply
How the effect is defined, what researchers think drives it, and how it is measured in trials like this one.
Products
Placebo pills for research and education
Inert capsules from Efficacy Labs, what they contain, and how to order them for a study or a classroom.
Continue reading
Randomized controlled trial
Open-label placebo in IBS (2010)
The trial that started modern open-label placebo research: patients were openly told their pills were inert placebos, and were still assessed against a no-treatment control.
Randomized controlled trial
Open-label placebo in chronic low back pain (2016)
An open-label placebo added on top of patients' existing treatment as usual for chronic low back pain, tested over three weeks in Portugal.
Randomized controlled trial
Labelling and migraine treatment (2014)
A within-subject migraine study that mislabelled and correctly labelled both a real drug and a placebo, isolating how much of the outcome tracked the label rather than the pill.